Keeping an extra house key nearby sounds smart in theory. We all want to avoid being locked out or stuck waiting for help in bad weather. But placing a spare key outside your home is never safe, no matter how clever the hiding spot seems. Thieves know all the usual spots. In fact, they count on it. Instead of reducing risk, an outdoor key makes it easier for someone to get in without breaking anything. That leaves little trace and gives them time inside. There are better, safer ways to handle access, and we’ll explain what works.
Burglars Already Know the Common Hiding Places
Most people choose hiding spots they assume no one will think to check. Yet, criminals go straight to those areas first. Under doormats, inside flower pots, beneath rocks, and on door ledges are always checked. These hiding methods don’t fool anyone who’s broken into homes before. Therefore, placing a key outside in one of these typical spots turns your front yard into an invitation.
We’ve seen this issue repeatedly during security assessments. People believe their chosen spot is unique, but it’s usually one of the first a thief checks. Even fake rocks designed for hiding keys often stand out. On top of that, many are lightweight and poorly disguised. A quick sweep of the porch or yard gives away the location.
If you want your home to feel more secure, start by removing that outside key. For safer options that don’t involve hidden access, a proper residential locksmith in Calgary can guide you through upgrades that fit your needs.
Trusted Access Should Be Given, Not Left Outside
Giving a spare key to someone you trust is far more secure than hiding one. When you hide a key, you have no idea who may find it. Even if it sits untouched for months, the risk stays. Once found, that person has full access and you won’t even know. But if a trusted friend, neighbor, or family member has your spare, you retain some control.
It also means you can update who has access. For example, if someone moves or changes roles in your life, you can get the key back. That’s not possible if a key disappears from the yard without notice. Keys handed directly to someone also create an opportunity to explain how and when to use it. There’s less guesswork, and fewer surprises.
So, if keeping a backup key nearby is important, choose someone you can call anytime. It adds a human layer of safety. And if you need to update locks after a change, locksmith in Calgary teams can rekey them without full replacements.
Lockboxes With Codes Are Not Foolproof
Many homeowners turn to wall-mounted lockboxes or combination boxes for spare keys. At first glance, these seem more secure. However, most over-the-counter models are not built to resist forced entry. Some have plastic parts. Others use cheap metal that cracks under pressure. Even combination models can be guessed or manipulated.
More importantly, once a lockbox is found, it signals that a spare key exists. That encourages intruders to focus on opening it, not looking elsewhere. In other words, it becomes a target. So, unless you’re using a commercial-grade version rated for impact and tamper resistance, it may cause more problems than it solves.
If you must install one for emergencies, place it in a less visible spot and avoid predictable codes. Change the combination often, especially after service workers or short-term guests have used it. Or, better still, ask about digital solutions when you explore home lock upgrades with a locksmith in Calgary.
Smart Locks Offer Better Control and Security
Spare keys belong to an older way of thinking. Today, smart locks remove the need to physically hide anything. With these locks, you create user codes that can be activated or removed whenever needed. There’s no need to copy or collect keys afterward. That simplifies who can get in and when.
You also gain logs of who entered and at what time. For families with teenagers or cleaners, that accountability brings peace of mind. Temporary codes can be issued to guests and then deleted. Even if someone shares the code, you can remove or replace it in minutes.
We’ve installed these systems for many families looking for better control. They work with phone apps, keypads, or even fingerprint access depending on the setup. To learn what options work best for your door and habits, a skilled Calgary locksmith can walk you through models that match your home layout and budget.
Hidden Keys Increase Insurance Complications
If someone enters your home with a key you left outside, the break-in might not count as forced entry. That creates issues with insurance claims. When there’s no sign of damage, providers often question the details of how entry occurred. In some cases, claims are denied or reduced due to suspected negligence.
Insurers expect homeowners to take reasonable steps to secure the property. Leaving a key outside, even inside a “hidden” container, may be seen as failing that standard. As a result, even if valuables are stolen, the financial loss might not be covered.
It’s important to think of spare keys as more than just convenience. They come with silent risk, not just physical but financial too. If you’ve already dealt with a break-in or want to avoid future disputes, we recommend you contact us for practical ways to reinforce your locks and remove hidden key dependence entirely.
FAQs
What if I need a backup in case of emergency?
Instead of hiding a key, give one to a trusted friend or neighbor. You can also install a smart lock that accepts temporary codes.
Can a fake rock or garden decoration really fool someone?
No. Most burglars know these products and often check them first. They are not reliable for long-term safety.
What’s the best way to secure access for service workers?
Use digital locks with user codes or arrange visits when you’re home. Avoid leaving keys outside for them to find.
Is it better to rekey locks than to hide a spare?
Yes. Rekeying gives you control over access. Hidden keys expose you to silent intrusions and theft.
Do all smart locks require Wi-Fi or internet?
No. Many smart locks work offline with keypads or Bluetooth. They offer flexibility without relying on internet access.